Page 3 of 3
Posted: Tue Mar 25, 2008 7:33 pm
by Rowana
For goodness sake, one of you say "Yes" and the other one "No"
I'm busy waiting for all the for and against points. All this agreement stuff does not make for interesting reading
Now get on with it
Posted: Tue Mar 25, 2008 11:19 pm
by Olivepage
"That's one of the secrets of TOP, if you needed to know the answer, it was normally there somewhere. If it wasn't, it wouldn't take long for someone to give it. "
True its always there.
Trouble is its invariably accompanied by at least 4 alternative answers whose supports will insist are right. 192 posts later the original question has been lost in torrents of abuse.
More seriously I have seen so much nonsense offered as answers, particularly about electrical, radio and electronics, many of them downright dangerous. Oddly the more outrageously wrong the answer the more vigorously the originator would argue its merit. I gave up on it long ago.
Posted: Tue Mar 25, 2008 11:31 pm
by Olivepage
"In all seriousness, getting back on board any boat is truly difficult but Claymore would be an absolute nightmare"
I have the same issues with Olive.
Standing orders are forget sails, fire up Pretty Polly and get the liferaft in the water as close as possible to the immersed one.
We can do the pulling, hauling and squabbling from there - actually with the power winches and time to set things up its relatively straightforward. The liferaft gives the time.
Posted: Wed Mar 26, 2008 1:28 pm
by T25
Olivepage wrote:More seriously I have seen so much nonsense offered as answers, particularly about electrical, radio and electronics, many of them downright dangerous. Oddly the more outrageously wrong the answer the more vigorously the originator would argue its merit. I gave up on it long ago.
That's the main reason I gave up even reading the PBO forum, and now haven't even looked in buttlescut or bomo for ages. If I want practical advice on a subject, without all the bickering, I look elsewhere. However, it would be good to see this become the one place where the good advice could be found.
Take Claysie for example. I must admit I hadn't thought about getting back aboard in an emergency, must remember to re-fit that folding ladder to the transom. Though on the East coast, you may as well just wear waders and walk ashore
Posted: Wed Mar 26, 2008 1:31 pm
by jim.r
claymore wrote:Agreeing with me does not constitute contradiction. Please make your contradiction - I'm rather looking forward to it.
yeah, you're right there..
Posted: Thu Mar 27, 2008 8:38 am
by claymore
Right that I'm right or right that I'm looking forward to it?